Are you in a hurry?
Here is a quick list of Bed and Breakfast in Shelter Island, selected based on their rating
| Name of hotel | Accommodation Rating | Facilities | Price, $ | |
| Abbey'S Lantern Hill Inn |
9.4 / 10 (72 Reviews) |
|
From 259$ | |
| Westbrook Inn Bed And Breakfast |
9.2 / 10 (27 Reviews) |
|
From 286$ | |
| Mill House Inn |
8.0 / 10 (74 Reviews) |
|
From 1155$ | |
| Jays Ranch Hamden |
4.6 / 10 (5 Reviews) |
|
From 81$ |
Best Bed & Breakfast in Shelter Island
View all photos
Abbey'S Lantern Hill Inn
From 259$
Luxury Bed & Breakfast in Shelter Island
View all photos
Westbrook Inn Bed And Breakfast
From 286$
Cheap Bed and Breakfast in Shelter Island
View all photos
Mill House Inn
From 1155$
Shelter Island Family-Friendly Bed & Breakfast
View all photos
Jays Ranch Hamden
From 81$
Hotels in Shelter Island
| Most comfortable Hotel 🛏️ | Abbey'S Lantern Hill Inn |
| Best reviews Hotel ❤️ | Westbrook Inn Bed And Breakfast |
| Best mid-range Hotel 🌴 | Mill House Inn |